Inchmahome Priory

  • Location: Inchmahome, near Port of Menteith, Stirling, FK8 3RA
  • Opening times: 1 April to 30 September, 10.00am – 4.30pm; 1 – 31 October, 10.00am – 3.00pm; 1 November to 31 March, closed.
  • Entry: Adult £10.00, concession £8.00, child (7 – 15) £6.00, under 7 free.
  • Access: Parking at ferry point, no charge.

I have a vague memory of a day out with a friend and his family, although who that friend was I can’t recall. Nor do I remember when this trip took place, save that it would have been in my early high school days at the latest. And crucially, I can’t even remember where on earth we visited. On the bright side, no one will be asking me what the Thirty-Nine Steps are anytime soon.

What I do remember, however, is making our way through moisture-jewelled grass towards a lakeside and getting soaked more from water drip-drip-dripping from the trees than from the smirry of rain. I know that’s a curious amount of detail considering the Big Stuff eludes me, but what can I say? The brain works in mysterious ways. After climbing aboard a small boat, a man rows us across the loch. A heavy mist languishes on the surface of the water, but as we near our island destination a blurry ruin, the remains of some ancient sacred site, can be glimpsed through the grey. To my young mind, it is all very mystical, all very Isle of Avalon.

Inchmahome is the tree-covered island in the centre of the photograph above.

Today there is neither mist nor mysticism. The sun is shining despite a fleet of clouds that traverses the sky in tight formation, and my fellow passengers and I speed across the water not in a rowing boat but one of those new-fangled things you might have heard about, a motor boat. Specifically the Mary Queen of Scots, one of three small boats (maximum number of passengers, 12) that ferry tourists from the Port of Menteith to Inchmahome island and back again. Our destination is Inchmahome Priory, and as we scud across the water the penny drops. This is where I went that long ago and largely unremembered day. Ha! One of life’s small – and niggling – mysteries, solved.

A fleeting glimpse of the priory as we approach the jetty.

Inchmahome is the largest of three islands in the Lake of Menteith, the only large, land-locked body of water in Scotland known as a lake rather than the usual loch. This, tradition tells us, is because one Sir John Menteith received the land on which the lake lies as a reward for his role in the betrayal and capture of Sir William Wallace in 1305. To ensure Menteith’s treachery was never forgotten, it quickly became customary for Scots to use the English lake instead of loch when referring to the body of water that bore his name.

It’s a good story, and one that I bought into for years, but tradition is talking bollocks. Old maps tell us that it was known as the Loch of Menteith well into the nineteenth century, when a cartographer made a simple error while compiling the first ordnance survey map of the area. All subsequent maps have followed suit, and it has been the Lake of Menteith ever since. As for it being the only lake in Scotland, say hello to Pressmennan Lake in the Lammermuir Hills, Hirsel Lake in Berwickshire, Lake Louise at Skibo Castle, and Cally Lake near Gatehouse of Fleet. Granted all of these are man-made whereas the Lake of Menteith is natural, but a lake’s a lake for a’ that.

Inchmahome Priory.

So much for the lake, on now to the priory. This was founded by Walter Comyn, 4th Earl of Menteith, circa 1238 CE for a group of Augustinian monks. As is often the case with sacred mediaeval places the priory was built on a site that had a pre-established religious settlement, one possibly dating back to the early Christian era. The island’s name is derived from the Gaelic Innis MoCholmaig meaning ‘the island of Colmaig’, an obscure Celtic saint (but then ain’t they all?).

Looking through the main entrance into the church.
The church interior.

The priory has seen some distinguished visitors over the years, including Robert the Bruce who visited three times, in 1306, 1308, and 1310. In September 1547, the four-year-old Mary Queen of Scots and her mother Mary of Guise were taken to Inchmahome for safety following the Scots’ crushing defeat at the Battle of Pinkie Cleugh. Mary stayed here for about three weeks before being shunted from safe house to safe house, eventually settling in Dumbarton Castle, from where she left for France in July 1548. Sir Walter Scott, often acknowledged as the ’Father of Scottish Tourism’, popularised Inchmahome and the nearby Trossachs in such romances as The Lady of the Lake and The Legend of Montrose. By Scott’s time, however, the priory had long since fallen into ruin, a victim of the Scottish Reformation of 1560 and beyond. In 1924, the 6th Duke of Montrose transferred care of the priory to the state, and it is now looked after by Historic Environment Scotland.

A memento mori on a gravestone in the choir. The priory is the final resting place of the adventurer and politician Robert Bontine Cunninghame Graham. He was a founder and first president of the Scottish Labour Party in the late nineteenth century before later founding the National Party of Scotland in 1928. He became the first president of its successor the Scottish National Party in 1934.
“Lords and ladies lie in stone / Hand in hand from long ago / And though their hands are cold they’ll love forever”. Chris de Burgh’s lyric could apply to these effigies, believed to be of Walter Stewart 5th Earl of Menteith and his wife Mary, Countess of Menteith.

Destination or Diversion?

That really depends on what you are looking for. The ferry crossing to the island is about seven minutes, a walk round the circumference about ten, and exploring the ruin about a half hour max. There isn’t a lot to do as the priory is in a glade on an island otherwise covered in trees, so for many it will be no more than a diversion. However, there is an immediate sense of tranquillity and seclusion on stepping ashore at Inchmahome, so you might want to soak some of that up for a longer spell, be it by simply admiring the scenery – check out how the shore-side trees all bow their branches down to drink the water – or perhaps settling down with a good book in the peaceful cloisters area. Note: Apart from the priory the only other building are a ticket office / small gift shop and a toilet block, so if you plan on lingering you might want to pack a picnic.

The Earl of Menteith and the Mary Queen of Scots; two of the boats that ferry visitors across to Inchmahome.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *