Muthill Old Church

  • Location: Station Road, Muthill, Crieff, PH5 2AR
  • Opening times: 24 hours all year round.
  • Entry: Free admission
  • Access: Roadside parking.

Typical. You wait ages to stumble upon the site of an old Culdees monastic community and two come along at once. The last brown sign I bagged was Abernethy Round Tower, built in the 1100s on land owned by the Culdees (derived from Céil De, Gaelic for ‘servants of God’), and – I’m joining some dots here as the origin of the Round Tower isn’t known for sure – presumably built by them. And now here I am at another mediaeval tower, a square one in the Romanesque style, 24 miles north-west of Abernethy at Muthill, a village just south of Crieff.  This one was also built in the 1100s, also on Culdees land.

Like the Abernethy Round Tower, this one remains largely intact, standing to its original height and retaining its roof. The Old Church has been less fortunate and exists today only as a skeletal ruin, despite being three centuries younger than the tower. The tower was once freestanding and part of an earlier church, but in the 1400s, long after the Culdees had gone, a larger church was constructed that ‘wrapped’ around the tower. When Muthill Old Church Building was deemed no longer fit for purpose, material was quarried from it when a new church was built 1826 – 1828, leaving only the dramatic sweeping archways seen today.

Taken with a wide-angle lens to show the arches to best effect.
Muthill Old Church back when it was just Muthill Church. Image taken from the information board on site and copyright Historic Scotland.
The church today.

And that’s about it as the story of Muthill Old Church goes, so we will turn instead to the far stranger story of someone that would have been familiar with the mediaeval building, Helen Gloag, born in the nearby hamlet of Wester Pett in 1750. When she was 19, Helen left Scotland for America, but two weeks into her voyage her ship was captured by pirates and she, along with all the other woman on board, was sold at an Algiers slave market. Her buyer then gifted her to Sultan Sidi Mohammed be Abdullah of Morocco, who was so infatuated with the red-haired, green-eyed beauty he made her his fourth wife, and, ultimately, his primary wife. In Scotland she was dubbed the ‘Empress of Morocco’, although this was just shorthand for her perceived status. Sultans had consorts rather than ‘queens’, and even if a sultan’s wife was granted a royal title it would be ‘Sultana’.

Following his father’s death in 1790 Moulay Yazid became the new sultan, and promptly bumped off potential rivals, including Helen’s two sons. Helen’s fate is unknown, but she is believed to have also been killed during Yazid’s chaotic two-year reign.

The story of a Scottish blacksmith’s daughter who became the ‘Empress of Morocco’ is quite a story, but – alas! – that’s all it might be. When a Dr. Lempriere was given permission to visit Sidi Mohammed’s harem the year before the sultan’s death, he made no mention of a Scottish slave, concubine, or sultan’s wife called Helen. The true story of Helen Gloag, therefore, remains one of history’s little mysteries.

Destination or Diversion?

My exploration of Muthill Old Church was over in about twenty minutes, and I probably lingered longer than most taking notes and photographs, so I suggest a stop here would be no more than a diversion.

The medieval church’s nineteenth century replacement.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *