- Location: 2 New High St, Headington, Oxford OX3 7AQ
- Opening times: 24 hours
- Entry: Free
- Access: Street parking
If you go down to New High Street today you’re bound for a big surprise, as the old nursery rhyme nearly said. A row of terraced houses runs down each side of the road, no different from similar such streets throughout England. No different, that is, apart from the 25ft-long fibreglass great white shark sticking out of the roof of number two, its head buried up to the gills somewhere beneath the rooftiles. It looks like it had been scooped up by a water spout and then unceremoniously dropped from a great height. This artwork, commissioned by one Bill Heine, designed by local sculptor John Buckley and built by Buckley and carpenter Anton Castiau, is officially called Untitled 1986, but is more commonly known as the Headington Shark.

This wasn’t Heine and Buckley’s first collaboration. American-born Bill Heine had lived in Oxford since the late 1960s, when he studied law at Balliol College, and by the mid-1970s was running the city’s Ultimate Picture Palace and Moulin Rouge Cinema. In 1976, he commissioned Buckley to create a pair of large Al Johnson-styled hands on the façade of the former, and called on the artist four years later to install a giant pair of ‘can-can’ legs above the latter. The can-can legs led to Heine’s first clash with Oxford City Council, who stated that the legs contravened planning laws by acting as an advertisement for the cinema. Heine’s response was to change the name of his picture house to Not the Moulin Rouge, and then ask, ‘how could a pair of can-can legs possibly be seen as advertising for a cinema called Not the Moulin Rouge?’ This simple act of chutzpah won the day, and the legs stayed.
When Buckley installed his Shark on the roof of Heine’s house in the early hours of Saturday 9 August 1986, another fight with the council was inevitable. The sculpture was unsafe and a danger to those in the house and the street outside, said the council, sending in a top team of roof specialists to prove this was the case. These boffins deviated from the script, however, reporting back that the shark had been expertly installed and presented no risk. The council responded by saying the shark couldn’t stay up in case it inspired others to do something similar, but it was pointed out that the shark had now been up for five years and not another house owner in all of Oxford had added a fearsome predator to their roof in that time.

Stymied, the council bumped their case on to the Department of the Environment, spluttering that the shark “was a slap in the face of the decent and respectable people” and “a victory for anarchy”. The DoE, under Michael Heseltine, tasked planning inspector Peter Macdonald with reviewing the case, and he wasn’t slow in letting the council down. “I cannot believe that the purpose of planning control”, concluded Macdonald, “is to enforce a boring and mediocre uniformity. Any system of control must make some space for the dynamic, the unexpected and the downright quirky, or we shall all be the poorer for it”. The Shark had won the day, and was here to stay.
But why did Heine want a shark on his roof? He claimed the idea came to him when he heard planes from RAF Heyford flying over his house on their way to bomb Libya, and was inspired to create a piece symbolic of death from above, and in particular the impotence and helplessness of the victims. The Shark, then, was a form of protest art, and it was purposely erected on the 41st anniversary of the bombing of Nagasaki on 9 August 1945. To be honest, the Libya story sounds like retrofitting, as according to Buckley, Heine’s idea was to have the Shark hanging over his front door. It was Buckley that suggested having it look as if it had just crashed into the roof, and the idea of using a shark in the first place also came from the artist.

In a surprise turnabout, Oxford City Council added the Shark to the city’s Heritage Assets List in 2022. Heine’s son Magnus Hanson-Heine, who bought the house in 2016, has mixed feelings about this. On one hand, he understands the role the shark plays as a tourist attraction, but on the other he is angry that the same council that once told his dad he couldn’t keep the sculpture up are now saying no one can take it down. To him, it means his father’s old adversaries have now taken control of the artwork.
I was captivated by the Shark the moment I saw it on the news at the time of its installation, first visited it a couple of years later, and have been back to see it several times since. It is one of my absolute favourite pieces of public art, and, while I can understand Hanson-Heine’s point, I applaud the council if their involvement ensures the Shark’s survival for future generations to come. Having said that, Oxford City Council is still being a dick. Hanson-Heine, who doesn’t live in Oxford, had been letting the Shark House out as an AirBNB, but was made to apply for retrospective planning permission for changing the house from residential to short stay accommodation in October 2023. Incredibly but perhaps unsurprisingly, they rejected his application and Shark House currently lies empty. It is all very well preserving the Shark, but a house only ever survives if it is inhabited, and I would imagine Shark House would attract plenty of temporary tenants bringing their tourist dollars to the city. I would certainly stay in it in a heartbeat. Get a grip, Oxford, and while you’re at it stick up some brown signs pointing the way to the Shark.

The Shark remains, but if anyone fancies embarking on an impromptu Heine-Buckley tourist trail then they are on to plumbs. The Moulin Rouge Cinema was demolished in 1991, although happily the can-can legs survive and can now be seen adorning the Duke of York cinema in Brighton. Conversely, the Ultimate Picture Palace still stands, but the Al Jolson hands disappeared when new owners restored the neo-classical façade in the mid-1990s. Bill Heine succumbed to cancer in 2019.
Destination or Diversion?
The Headington Shark is quirky and wonderful, but it is a quirky and wonderful diversion. You drive to New High Street, get out the car, admire the Shark (it will almost certainly bring a smile to all first-time visitors), take some photos, get back in the car, and drive off. Nonetheless, and despite the fact it is a distance from the city centre, I think the Shark is one of Oxford’s must-sees.
