- Location: Arched House, High Street, Ecclefechan, Lockerbie, DG11 3DG
- Opening times: 23 March to 29 September, 10.00am – 2.00pm. Closed the rest of the year except 4 December, Carlyle’s birthday.
- Entry: Adult £5.00, family £10.00, one adult family £8.00, concession £4.00
- Access: On street parking
Thomas Carlyle’s Birthplace is one of two brown signs that inspired this blog, the other being the Museum of Lead Mining, which I will visit later on today’s travels. I pass these two brown signs every time I take the A74/M74 south to England and have often wondered what these visitor attractions are like, and whether they were worth taking the detour. This whole website is about “taking the detour” to visit attractions both on and off the beaten track, but it is only now, over 130 entries later, that I am getting around to the two that first planted the idea in my head.
Surprisingly, quite a few people do make the detour. There were another four visitors when I was there, and according to ALVA (the Association of Leading Visitor Attractions), Carlyle’s Birthplace attracted 1,158 people during the six months of opening in 2023. That might not seem a lot, but J. M Barrie’s Birthplace only got 2,144 visitors, a mere thousand people more, and he invented Peter Pan! And Captain Hook! And Wendy (not just the character, but the girl’s name)! Who did Thomas Carlyle invent?
Exactly.

Like Barrie, Carlyle was a prolific writer. He wrote essays about whatever topic happened to flit across his mind; histories such as The French Revolution (1837) and Frederick the Great (1858 – 1865); a novel Sartor Resartus (1831); wrote poetry, social commentary and thought pieces; translated many works of German literature, particularly Goethe; edited the letters of Oliver Cromwell; and much more besides.
Unlike Barrie, Carlyle was regarded as one of the great writers and thinkers of his time. Here is a partial list of familiar 19th and 20th century faces that acknowledged his writing or philosophy as an influence: Elizabeth Barret Browning, Robert Browning, Benjamin Disraeli, W. E. B Du Bois, George Elliot, Friedrich Engels, Mahatma Gandhi, James Joyce, Martin Luther King, Karl Marx, Emmeline Pankhurst, John Ruskin, and George Bernard Shaw. Ralph Waldo Emerson called him “a secular prophet” and the “undoubted head of English letters”. Charles Dickens said he “would go further to see Carlyle than any man alive”. Carlyle unknowingly served as one of the models for the face of Christ in William Holman Hunt’s three The Light of the World paintings. We’ll get to someone else he influenced a bit later, but first let’s go to the house in Ecclefechan (meaning ‘little church’) where he was born.


An 80th birthday tribute to Carlyle, signed by many prominent Victorians including Alfred Lord Tennyson, Robert Browning, Margaret Oliphant, Anthony Trollope, and (above right) Charles Darwin and his brother Erasmus. Carlyle described the latter as “one of the sincerest, truest and most modest of men”, and these words were inscribed on Erasmus Darwin’s grave slab.

This distinctive white two-storey dwelling with its central archway and Venetian windows was built in 1791 by Carlyle’s father and uncle, stone masons both, and is on the right as one drives down the High Street. Various websites tell me that the building is “a fine example of Scottish 18th century vernacular architecture”, so that’s nice, and it comprises two conjoined houses, with the dividing wall situated at the top of the arch. In his Reminiscences, Carlyle hoped that his writing would be comparable to his father’s house, i.e. strong enough to last the ages,
The house is now owned by the National Trust for Scotland, and is essentially a collection of Carlyle memorabilia housed in an authentic village dwelling circa 1800, with much of the furniture, fittings and household items having once belonged to either Carlyle or his parents. I was given a potted biography of Carlyle by the NTS employee holding the fort, who also informed me that Carlyle’s Birthplace opened as a museum three years after the man’s death in 1881, thus making it the second oldest birthplace museum in the UK after Shakespeare’s (Note: Burns Cottage, for example, is an older building than Carlyle’s Birthplace but did not open as a museum until the early 1900s).







That concluded my Carlyle-themed tour of Ecclefechan but I came away feeling I had only gained a superficial understanding of the man, and still didn’t understand why he was considered such a B. M. O. 19thc. C. So I did some research when I got back home and while I didn’t find the answers I was looking for I did find myself wondering if Carlyle is someone we should even be commemorating at all. The man was an unapologetic racist, believing “It is a natural aristocracy, that of colour, and quite right that the stronger and better race should have dominion” and calling slavery “the precious thing”. He was also an antisemite, stating that Jews had added nothing to “the wealth of mankind” and that they should all confine themselves to their “own wretched Palestine as soon as possible”. Various writers have also identified Carlyle as a proto fascist, which brings us neatly to that other admirer mentioned earlier. Adolf Hitler and the Nazi hierarchy were fans, and Joseph Goebbels read passages from Frederick the Great to Hitler during their final days in the bunker in Berlin.
Destination or Diversion?
It doesn’t take long to go around the house’s three small rooms and the graveyard and monument are just short walks away, so I’m calling this a diversion only.

